Zwarte piet/black pete
Oct. 24th, 2013 04:31 pmIt is Dutch custom to celebrate the feast of St. Nicholas on the eve of 5 December. On this night, the saint visits every house and brings presents with him for the children. St. Nicholas is accompanied by his helper, who is called Black Pete. Through the years, the saint has gathered more and more helpers, all of them black, with red lips and big golden earrings. Traditionally, Black Pete is played by Dutch (white) people who put on blackface and the matching outfit.
Some say that Black Pete is of african descent and that is why he is black. Others say that Black Pete is black because he climbs through chimney's to deliver packages. F
Fact 1: putting on blackface is racist
Fact 2: referring to people as helpers is not racist
Fact 3: portraying all the helpers surrounding St. Nick as black people: why?
Here's a picture of St. Nick driving into town on his rooftop climbing white horse.

Solutions have been offered in previous year to make some changes in order to make this annual festivity less racist. For example, Black St. Nick and White Pete:

Or Pete's in every color! Rainbow Pete:

This year, the discussion around Black Pete is bigger then ever. Even the UN is chipping in, with a research into the question: is the tradition of portraying black people in a stereotypical way racist?. I can save them the effort: yes, it is racist to put a charicature of a person in black face out there. That is why the role of Pete has been changing through the years: he doesn't talk with a stereotypical accent any more. The lips are less pronounced and there are many more new Pete's helping St. Nick who are all individual people, with their own strengths and weeknesses. We are not there yet, but changing the world takes time.
My conclusion of the whole discussion is that the (Dutch) media have too much time on their hands and they are filling it with talking about Black Pete. Public outrage is fine, as long as it is channeled towards finding a solution. So far I have seen very few constructive solutions. How about turning Pete into a real person instead of a character?
What is your opinion?
Some say that Black Pete is of african descent and that is why he is black. Others say that Black Pete is black because he climbs through chimney's to deliver packages. F
Fact 1: putting on blackface is racist
Fact 2: referring to people as helpers is not racist
Fact 3: portraying all the helpers surrounding St. Nick as black people: why?
Here's a picture of St. Nick driving into town on his rooftop climbing white horse.

Solutions have been offered in previous year to make some changes in order to make this annual festivity less racist. For example, Black St. Nick and White Pete:

Or Pete's in every color! Rainbow Pete:

This year, the discussion around Black Pete is bigger then ever. Even the UN is chipping in, with a research into the question: is the tradition of portraying black people in a stereotypical way racist?. I can save them the effort: yes, it is racist to put a charicature of a person in black face out there. That is why the role of Pete has been changing through the years: he doesn't talk with a stereotypical accent any more. The lips are less pronounced and there are many more new Pete's helping St. Nick who are all individual people, with their own strengths and weeknesses. We are not there yet, but changing the world takes time.
My conclusion of the whole discussion is that the (Dutch) media have too much time on their hands and they are filling it with talking about Black Pete. Public outrage is fine, as long as it is channeled towards finding a solution. So far I have seen very few constructive solutions. How about turning Pete into a real person instead of a character?
What is your opinion?